The Best Retro Horror Games Of All Time

Key Takeaways

• Playing retro horror games can offer a refreshing change from recent titles, providing unique experiences.
• Many retro horror games are still considered exceptional and offer rich entertainment value without being too scary.
• Despite the expense, retro horror games like Sweet Home and Illbleed are worth experiencing for their unique stories and gameplay.

If you love horror games but only have the newest gaming systems, you might get tired of all the recent horror titles and want to spice it up a bit. In that case, it’s a perfect time to play a retro horror game.

These are often vastly different than what you get today in the horror genre but are still just as good, if not better. Unfortunately, the downside to going retro is that it’s going to hurt your wallet because, depending on how you get a hold of them, these retro titles tend to be extremely expensive. Some are definitely more accessible than others, though.

Updated on October 3, 2024, by Dominic Allen: The October season is the perfect time to replay horror game classics or experience retro titles you’ve heard are great but never played before. Some of these retro horror games are still the cream of the crop in the genre. Even more entries were added this time, including some retro PC games. PC titles were completely absent prior, so it’s time for them to see some love.

14 Phantasmagoria 2

The Best Retro FMV Horror Game

Not all good horror games need to be scary, as they can also provide rich entertainment value, and that’s exactly the case for Phantasmagoria 2. The first Phantasmagoria was solid and quite entertaining, but nothing compares to the sequel. You can jump straight in, too, and it’s not like you need to play the first one.

An FMV point-and-click adventure game that definitely leans more towards being an interactive movie, it’s one of the most entertaining games in the genre. It’ll give you a lot of laughs and a lot of fun, and those types of games are equally worth playing in rotation with traditional horror titles.

13 System Shock 2

Still One Of The Best PC Games Ever Made

System Shock 2 is a game that saw love at release but didn’t earn that all-time great status until much later. Some of the greatest games of these past few generations, like BioShock 1 and the 2017 Prey, would not exist without the influence of System Shock.

System Shock 2, especially, was such a massive leap in quality in terms of atmosphere, story, and gameplay that there’s a reason the original game got a full-blown remake and not its sequel.

System Shock 2 also heightened the horror elements, and it was one of the first horror games that really nailed the space setting that future titles like Dead Space 1 would perfect. If you can look past the dated graphics, this game remains a banger PC-exclusive horror immersive sim.

12 Resident Evil 3: Nemesis

The Best Of The PS1 Trilogy

Most of the Resident Evil remakes are excellent, but if there’s one that definitely doesn’t match up to the original, it has to be RE3. The original introduced one of the greatest villains in all of horror gaming, introduced several amazing new gameplay features and satisfyingly wrapped up the Raccoon City trilogy. The replay value here is great because every playthrough will be a little bit different.

In one spot, Brainsuckers can spawn or the far more deadly Hunters, and the same with items spawns. There are dynamic choices you can make as well, randomized puzzles, and if you want to go pro, you can kill Nemesis numerous times for lucrative item drops. Out of all the PS1 RE games, Resident Evil 3 is the one that never gets boring, even after numerous playthroughs.

11 Silent Hill 3

The Fan Favorite

While Silent Hill 2 is still critically regarded as the best in the series, over time, the fan-favorite Silent Hill game has shifted to SH3. Silent Hill 3 is just the best raw horror game in the franchise, with the best monsters, environments, music, and sound design. It’s wild that Team Silent pulled off these environments on the PS2 because they’re still effective in scaring the pants off you.

A direct sequel to Silent Hill 1, SH3 wraps up the storyline perfectly in a way that seems natural and pre-planned, even though it wasn’t. The cast of characters is great, and all around, SH3 is the perfect Silent Hill game and, frankly, close to a perfect horror game in general.

10 Dino Crisis

The Next Evolution Of Resident Evil

Capcom’s Dino Crisis series is one that many want to come back. The last entry was back on the original Xbox, but the first two games were really damn good. Dino Crisis 1 is the entry more focused on pure horror, and at release, it was probably the peak of the genre in terms of mechanical complexity.

These Dinos are much smarter than your Resident Evil Zombies. They actively hunt you, can go into rooms, and get harder as you progress. You might think this game’s pretty easy at first, but when you get to the second half, the difficulty ramps up significantly. With high replay value and multiple endings, it’s a great PS1 horror title. It’s even coming to PS5 through PS Plus, so there’s no excuse not to check this game out.

9 Haunting Ground

One Of The Best Horror Games On The PS2

Haunting Ground is such a good game, and sadly, many won’t be able to play it because it’s one of the most expensive games on the PS2. Taking place in an awesome atmospheric castle, you play as Fiona and bond with a dog named Hewie to escape. This is a true M for Mature title because the dark content, subject matter, and villain motivation are really disturbing.

Haunting Ground has one of the most messed up bad endings you’ll ever find in a game. Its gameplay is similar to an improved Clock Tower due to the large number of available options you have. This includes your best bud Hewie, which can attack your pursuer. Haunting Ground does have some backtracking issues, but besides that, it’s a phenomenal ride of a horror game.

8 Sweet Home

The True Beginning Of Resident Evil

If you’re looking for a horror masterpiece to play that you’ve never experienced, you must check out Sweet Home for the NES. This is especially true if you’re a Resident Evil fan, as Sweet Home is essentially its progenitor. A Japanese-exclusive game based on the 1989 horror film Sweet Home is an RPG survival horror hybrid.

Both aspects hold up amazingly today. Compared to most other NES RPGs, Sweet Home remains pretty accessible to modern players. Many younger gamers will likely drop most other NES RPGs due to their dated elements, but not so much here. Combined with a great story with many twists and turns, you have a must-play retro horror title.

7 Illbleed

A Wildly Fun Trip

Another incredibly expensive horror gem is Illbleed for the Dreamcast. Taking place in a horror-themed amusement park, you go through six levels of pure chaos. It’s a truly wild horror title for the time. Much of the gameplay uses your camera to spot traps in a manner very similar to Minesweeper.

It’s great once you get it down, but the combat is the usual clunkiness you’d see at the time. Regardless, the story, cutscenes, and ridiculous things that occur really hooks you. It’s one of those games you continue to play just to see what wild stuff happens next.

6 Parasite Eve

A Top-Tier RPG On The PS1

Square Enix’s major horror series is Parasite Eve, and out of the trilogy, you can’t top the original. Its soundtrack is outstanding, and it offers a unique but fun battle system, along with a great story as well. Aya Brea is a phenomenal female protagonist and definitely up there with the best female horror leads in gaming.

It is among the best RPGs on the PS1, and unfortunately, neither of its two sequels was even close in quality. What’s also really cool is that Parasite Eve has neat post-game content with a 77-floor mega-dungeon, the Chrysler Building. That will truly test your skills.

5 Zombies Ate My Neighbors

The LucasArts 16-Bit Classic

One of the best 16-bit horror games has to be Zombies Ate My Neighbors by LucasArts. The enemy variety is virtually unmatched in the horror genre, plus you have a wide variety of locations, too. In the game, you must rescue ten neighbors, and after rescuing them all, you can continue to the next level. They can die, though, and if all ten perish, it’s game over.

Even though the title is more of a 2D action game, it does feel like survival horror in terms of managing your scarce resources. This especially comes into play with the bosses, which require a ton of firepower to kill. Luckily, you can play Zombies Ate My Neighbors on modern platforms, so you won’t need to empty your wallet for it.

4 Siren: Blood Curse

Incredibly Underrated

While Siren: Blood Curse is a PS3 game, it released in 2008, which should be old enough to make it retro. Blood Curse is one of the best horror games on the PS3 and one of the best of the generation. A reimagining of the first game, Blood Curse does a great job of disempowering you to make the experience more scary.

A great example of this is the level where you play as a defenseless little girl. Blood Curse is a real hidden gem as it was released digital-only in the West. Keep in mind this was 2008, when physical purchases were still the large majority. Since Siren is a first-party Sony IP, they should definitely do more with the series, and a full PS5 remake of Blood Curse would be awesome.

3 Fatal Frame 2: Crimson Butterfly

The Best Fatal Frame Game

Fatal Frame 2: Crimson Butterfly is one of those sequels vastly superior in almost every way. The first game was solid but had many flaws, like exploring the same areas countless times. The second game has a better story, better atmosphere, better puzzles, and better replay value with more endings.

It’s much scarier than the original, and even people more resistant to horror games will still be affected. Crimson Butterfly is the peak of the series, and a remaster would be nice as the first three installments are a bit pricey nowadays.

2 Silent Hill

Where It All Began

A lot of people would put Silent Hill 2 here, but the first game is the best place to start in the series. Plus, it has a much higher quality than something like the first Fatal Frame, so you shouldn’t skip it. SH1 is still scary today, even with its old visuals.

Be warned that you must actually pay attention to know what’s going on in the story. If you don’t read text files in games like Starfield or Cyberpunk 2077, that behavior is punished here. However, it’s so awesome when you finally connect all the dots after looking into everything. Truly great horror never ages, and Silent Hill 1 is a good example.

1 Resident Evil Remake

The Gold Standard

The peak of old-school survival horror is the 2002 Resident Evil remake. In an incredibly unique scenario, this remake is directed by the same person as the original, Shinji Mikami. This gives the remake an authentic feel of a creator truly expanding upon and fulfilling the vision he originally wanted. Not only are the prerendered backgrounds better than ever, but many gameplay tweaks were added.

Zombies can now barge into rooms; more surprise attacks were included, and of course, the deadly Crimson Heads. Many of these tweaks further challenge you to plan out your routes in the most efficient manner. For the longest time, the Resident Evil 1 remake has been the standard example of how to do a video game remake, and it’s for good reason.