The Best Food Cards In MTG

It may be hard to believe now, but there was a time when the tables of Magic: The Gathering lay bare, with nary a scrap of sustenance in sight. This all changed with Throne of Eldraine, which introduced Food tokens: an extremely flavorful addition, both literally and figuratively.




Magic: The Gathering – The 10 Best Cards In Lord Of The Rings’ Food And Fellowship Commander Deck

Party like it’s 1954!

Since then, Food tokens have reared their tasty heads in many other expansions and products, resulting in a suite (sweet?) of synergistic options for any deck dedicated to their creation. These are the very best cards in that category: the show-stopping centrepieces that look just as good on the dinner table as they do on your playmat.

10 Asmoranomardicadaistinaculdacar And The Underworld Cookbook

Stoke The Culinary Coals

MTG: Asmoranomardicadaistinaculdacar and The Underworld Cookbook cards

It may seem like cheating to include two cards in a single entry, but that’s honestly on-theme for Asmoranomardicadaistinaculdacar, a card with such an unusual casting condition that playing it at all feels like cheating in a sense. In addition, the two blend so perfectly that it’s unlikely you’d ever run one without the other.

Once you cast Asmoranomardicadaistinaculdacar, you can tutor up her trusty Underworld Cookbook, an all-in-one Food creation engine and discard outlet. This helps to set up Asmoranomardicadaistinaculdacar’s surprisingly potent removal effect, which one can only imagine involves force-feeding opposing creatures to death, and can even bring her back later on if need be.

9 Gilded Goose

Your Goose Is Cooked

MTG: Gilded Goose card

Birds of Paradise is a multi-format staple for good reason, and Gilded Goose is a worthy sidegrade that introduces a multitude of play possibilities. While it can only serve as a mana dork for a single turn initially, there are so many cards that produce Food tokens that it can reliably supply you with ramp and fixing for much of the game.

This alone would likely make Gilded Goose worth playing, but it has one final trick up its wing: the ability to produce Food itself, at an extremely reasonable rate. This gives the card value long after most mana dorks have given up the Goose, and makes it an auto-include in most Food-centric lists.

8 Cauldron Familiar

Flan’s Best Friend

MTG: Cauldron Familiar card

One of the most infamous Food support cards ever printed, this cunning Cat should be Familiar to anyone who’s played Magic at all since 2020. The lack of any limits on its reanimation effect, combined with a simple drain-life-on-entering trigger, results in a card that enables more combos than a premium fightstick.


Magic: The Gathering – 10 Budget Upgrades For Lord Of The Rings’ Food And Fellowship Commander Deck

Here are some flexible menu options for this food-centered commander deck.

Most players cottoned on to the synergy Cauldron Familiar has with Witch’s Oven early on, and the two went on to define their very own deck type, the notorious, and aptly-named, Cat-Oven. Beyond that, though, the card plays so well with so many different Food generators that it’s almost harder not to combo off with it once it’s in your deck.

7 Restless Cottage

The Last Gingerbread House On The Left

MTG: Restless Cottage card

Creature lands have always been strong performers across a range of formats, Standard and Commander in particular, and Wilds of Eldraine’s Restless Cottage is no exception. In exchange for entering tapped, you get a green/black land that can transform into a beefy 4/4 creature, with not-insignificant upsides, when needed.

Each time the Cottage attacks you not only get to exile something from a graveyard, letting you combat Reanimator decks and the like, but you also get to create a Food token. This is a nice bit of incidental value, and one that elevates Restless Cottage from a solid tech card to a staple inclusion in the majority of Food decks.

Crumble Before This Fighting Food

MTG: Tough Cookie card

One of the best ways to keep track of power creep in Magic is to check what kinds of creatures you can get for two mana in a recent set. Back in Alpha it would pay for a vanilla 2/2 Bear with no abilities, but in Wilds of Eldraine it gets you a 2/2 Food Golem with a veritable smorgasbord of upside.

Not only is Tough Cookie a Food itself, giving it synergy with everything else on this list and beyond, but it also gives you another food on entry, and can turn your Food, or any noncreature artifacts, into 4/4’s for a reasonable cost.

5 Oko, Thief Of Crowns

The Prodigal Son Of The Food Archetype

MTG: Oko, Thief of Crowns card

Oko needs no introduction. In terms of multi-format impact, he may just be the most broken modern Magic card ever printed, creating a very reasonable case for expanding the Power Nine to a Power Ten. Even today, after four years worth of dust settling, he remains banned in five different constructed formats.

This is largely down to his ridiculous +1 ability, which can nullify any threat while also bolstering Oko’s loyalty, but his +2, which makes a Food token, is no slouch either. It creates a six loyalty planeswalker for just three mana, and gives you a valuable resource in the progress, making him a Food deck staple in the three formats he’s still legal in.

4 Feasting Troll King

Why Pay Mana When You Can Pay Food?

MTG: Feasting Troll King card

Any time a Magic card gives you the option of substituting a different resource, be it life, creatures, or cards in graveyards, for mana, that card is worth a second look. Feasting Troll King does just that, letting you cast a monstrous 7/6 vigilant trampler for free if you have three Foods to sacrifice, and the King himself is in your graveyard.


Magic: The Gathering – The 14 Best Commanders For A Horror Deck

The terrifying commanders of your nightmares.

Those conditions are surprisingly easy to achieve, meaning you can get this creature out very early on in many circumstances. Even if your opponent can remove it, unless they can exile it too it’ll just keep coming back every time you reach three Foods, making their eventual defeat all but inevitable.

3 Samwise Gamgee

But What About Infinite Breakfasts?

MTG: Samwise Gamgee card

The Hobbits of The Lord of the Rings are well-known for their voracious appetites, but Samwise Gamgee takes the concept to a whole new level. Combined with Cauldron Familiar and any kind of sacrifice outlet, Samwise can create infinite Food tokens, and infinite damage, incredibly easily.

This is largely due to his first ability, which gives you a Food whenever a nontoken creature enters the battlefield under your control. This raw combo potential alone is enough to warrant Sam’s place on this list, but he also plays perfectly well as a fair card too, thanks to his grindy second ability.

2 Night Of The Sweets’ Revenge

A Dish Best Served Cold

MTG: Night of the Sweets' Revenge card

A card that really rewards you for going all-in on the Food archetype, Night of the Sweets’ Revenge is a Food token, ramp engine, and win condition for the deck all in one. Turning all of your Foods into Llanowar Elves is excellent, giving the tokens themselves some much-needed utility, but the second ability is where things get really interesting.

For seven mana, you can unleash a kind of mega-Overrun effect that scales up based on the Foods you have in play. The Foods themselves can largely pay for this cost thanks to the mana production ability, at which point all you’ll need is some evasive creatures to finish off the majority of games.

1 Brenard, Ginger Sculptor

The Great Multiverse Bake Off

MTG: Brenard, Ginger Sculptor card

One of the hand-crafted, archetype-specific commanders that have become incredibly common in recent years, Brenard is the best Food deck commander in the game and it’s not particularly close. Not only does he give a huge boost to your Food creatures, the Gingerbrutes and Tough Cookies of the world, but he also creates them each time one of your creatures dies.

Creating 1/1 Food Golems would be good enough, but the fact that those tokens also inherit the abilities of the deceased pushes this so far over the top that it reaches the stratosphere. Brenard is so powerful, in fact, that he single-handedly gives Food decks legs, albeit stubby gingerbread legs, in the Commander format.


Magic: The Gathering – The 10 Best Commanders In Universes Beyond: Doctor Who

These are the strongest and most useful commanders from the Doctor Who set.

Leave a Comment